Last Wednesday, moments after Felix Hernandez tossed the 23rd perfect game in MLB history against the Tampa Bay Rays, we looked at how pitchers fared in their next trip to the bump.
The history dates so far back, that I wasn’t able to obtain box scores pre-1922. For the sake of this article, my perfect game followups begin with Charlie Robertson of the White Sox, who threw his perfect game on April 30, 1922. On May 5th, he toed the rubber while facing the Indians’ — just like King Felix will do this evening at Safeco Field — and he just didn’t have the same gusto. In six innings, Anderson gave up four runs on nine hits, while taking the 6-3 loss to Cleveland.
Fast forward nine decades, Philip Humber and Matt Cain achieved perfection 54-days apart earlier this year. Philip Humber turned in a stinker for his followup performance, giving up nine runs on eight hits in five innings of work against the Red Sox. Matt Cain on the other hand, was able to get his Giants’ to the winners circle against the Angels despite not having his best stuff (5 IP, 6H, 3ER).
From a sports betting perspective, pitchers have not brought their “A” game after perfection. All told, the eighteen pitchers with followup games on record have averaged 6.2 innings pitched with a 5.35 ERA, while sporting a 6-8 record with four no decisions.
Currently, the Mariners’ and Felix Hernandez are -210 favorites on the majority of sports betting sites over the Cleveland Indians tonight ($100 bet wins $47.62).
Here are the pitchers stat lines for the following start after their perfect game:
Charlie Robertson, White Sox, vs. Cleveland, May 5, 1922: 6 ip, 9 h, 4 r, 4 er, 3 bb, 3 K (L). Final score: Indians 6, White Sox 3
Don Larsen, Yankees, vs. Boston, April 20, 1957: 1.1 ip, 5 h, 4 r, 4 er, 1 bb, 0 K (ND)* Final score: Yankees 10, Red Sox 7.
Jim Bunning, Phillies, vs. St. Louis, June 26, 1964: 7 ip, 11 h, 4 r, 4 er, 0 bb, 5 K (ND). Final score: Phillies 6, Cardinals 5.
Sandy Koufax, Dodgers. vs. Cubs, Sept. 14, 1965: 6 ip, 5 h, 2 r, 1 er, 0 bb, 3 K (L). Final score: Cubs 2, Dodgers 1.
Catfish Hunter, A’s, vs. Twins, May 14, 1968: 6 ip, 8 h, 8 r, 8 er, 5 bb, 4 K (W); Final score: A’s 13, Twins 8.
Len Barker, Indians, vs. Mariners, May 20, 1981: 9 ip, 8 h, 3 r, 3 er, 1 bb, 10 K (L). Final score: Mariners 3, Indians 1.
Mike Witt, Angels, vs. Twins, Apirl 9, 1985: 7.2 ip, 10 h, 4 r, 4 er, 3 bb, 3 K (L). Final score: Twins 6, Angels 2*.
Tom Browning, Reds, vs. Giants, Sept. 21, 1988: 8 ip, 5 h, 1 r, 1 er, 1 bb, 4 K (W). Final score: Reds 5, Giants 1.
Dennis Martinez, Expos, vs. Phillies, Aug. 12, 1991: 7 ip, 6 h, 4 r, 4 er, 2 bb, 4 K (ND). Final score: Phillies 6, Expos 5.
Kenny Rogers, Rangers, vs. White Sox, Aug. 2, 1994: 5.1 ip, 6 h, 5 r, 4 er, 3 bb, 2 K (L). Final score: White Sox 6, Rangers 2.
David Wells, Yankees, vs. Red Sox, May 23, 1998: 7 ip, 5 h, 3 r, 3 er, 1 bb, 5 K (W). Final score: Yankees 12, Red Sox 3.
David Cone, Yankees, vs. Indians, July 23, 1998: 4 ip, 6 h, 6 r, 2 er, 4 bb, 7 K (ND). Final score: Yankees 9, Indians 8.
Randy Johnson, Diamondbacks, vs. Marlins, May 23, 2004: 7 ip, 4 h, 2 r, 2 er, 1 bb, 5 K (W). Final score: Diamondbacks 4, Marlins 3.
Mark Buehrle, White Sox, vs. Twins, July 28, 2009: 6.1 ip, 5 h, 5 r, 5 er, 1 bb, 5 K (L). Final score: Twins 5, White Sox 3.
Dallas Braden, A’s, vs. Angels, May 14, 2010: 8 ip, 7 h, 4 r, 4 er, 1 bb, 5 K (L). Final score: Angels 4, A’s 0.
Roy Halladay, Phillies, vs. Padres, June 4, 2010: 7 ip, 10 h, 2 r, 2 er, 1 bb, 7 K (W). Final score: Phillies 3, Padres 2.
Philip Humber, White Sox, vs. Red Sox, April 26, 2012: 5 ip, 8 h, 9 r, 9 er, 3 bb, 5 K (L). Final score: Red Sox 10, White Sox 3.
Matt Cain, Giants, vs. Angels, June 18, 2012: 5 ip, 6 h, 3 r, 3 er, 4 bb, 4 K (W). Final score: Giants 5, Angels 3.
Felix Hernandez, TBD…